Imperative and Dispositive Norms in Legal Regulation of Genetic Research in Russia. / Normas imperativas y dispositivas en la regulación legal de la investigación genética en Rusia.

  • MAXIM VALER'EVICH VORONIN Kazan Federal University.Russia
  • MARIA VLADIMIROVNA ZAKHAROVA Kutafin Moscow State Law University. Russia
  • NATALIIA VLADIMIROVNA KOZLOVA Moscow State University. Russia




The article is devoted to the analysis of diverse utilization varieties of regulatory framework at adjusting genetic techniques and global legal practice research. Internal determinants of the development of national systems and external universal laws of legal transformation influence the evolution of views of the professional community of lawyers in Russia and in foreign countries, regarding the choice of dispositive or mandatory ways of regulating genetic research. The discussion on a number of legal institutions and on the choice of effective methods and forms of legal regulation in the world and Russian legal practice continues.



El artículo está dedicado al análisis de diversas variedades de utilización del marco regulatorio para ajustar las técnicas genéticas y la investigación de la práctica legal global. Los determinantes internos del desarrollo de los sistemas nacionales y las leyes universales externas de transformación legal influyen en la evolución de los puntos de vista de la comunidad profesional de abogados en Rusia y en países extranjeros, con respecto a la elección de formas obligatorias o dispositivas para regular la investigación genética. Continúa el debate sobre una serie de instituciones jurídicas y sobre la elección de métodos y formas eficaces de regulación jurídica en el mundo y la práctica jurídica rusa.


BLEDSOE, MJ (2017). "Ethical legal and social issues of biobanking: past, present, and future." Biopreservation and biobanking, 15(2), pp.142-147.

BOGGIO, A (2017). "Population biobanks’ governance: A case study of knowledge commons." Governing Medical Knowledge Commons, pp.102-120.

DIERICKX, K & BORRY, P (2009). "New challenges for biobanks: ethics, law and governance."Antwerp: Intersentia.

D'YAKOV,VG (2020). "Some Legal Aspects of Regulation of the Relations Arising during the Use of Postgenomic Technologies."Kutafin University Bulletin (Moscow State Law Academy), pp.108-113.

FAGOT-LARGEAULT,A (1985). "L’homme bioéthique."Pour une déontologie de la recherchesur le vivant. Paris: Maloine, Recherchesinterdisciplinaires.

HAGA, SB & BESKOW, LM (2008). "Ethical, legal, and social implications of biobanks for genetics research." Advances in genetics, 60(11), pp.505-544.

HAINAUT, P, VAUGHT, J, ZATLOUKAL, K & PASTERK, M (2017). "Biobanking of Human Biospecimens."Springer, Cham.

HANSSON, MG (2009). "Ethics and biobanks." British journal of cancer, 100(1), pp.8-12.

HOTTOIS,G (2007). "L'éthique en comités."Journal International de Bioéthique, 2(18), pp.35-46.

KVIT, N (2017). "Biobank: problems of legal regulation." Visegrad journal on human rights, 93(5).

LANGHOF, H, SCHWIETERING, J & STRECH, D (2019). "Practice evaluation of biobank ethics and governance: current needs and future perspectives." Journal of medical genetics, 56(3), pp.176-185.

LAURIE, G (2011). "Reflexive governance in biobanking: on the value of policy led approaches and the need to recognise the limits of law." Human genetics, 130(3).

MASCALZONI,D (2015). "Ethics, Law and Governance of Biobanking."National, European and International Approaches.

PARODI, B (2015). "Biobanks: A definition." In Ethics, law and governance of biobanking,Springer, Dordrecht.

PRZHILENSKIY, VI (2020). "Black Holes in Legislation and Gray Zones of Ethics: Committees on Ethics in the Structure of Legal Regulation of Genetic Research." Kutafin University Bulletin (Moscow State Law Academy),pp.57-68.

REGALADO,A (2018). "Hundreds of crimes will soon be solved using DNA databases, genealogist predicts."MIT Technol. Rev.

REICH, WT (1995). Encyclopedia of bioethics.

SAVATT, J, PISIECZKO, CJ, ZHANG, Y, LEE, MTM, FAUCETT, WA & WILLIAMS, JL (2019). "Biobanks in the Era of Genomic Data." Current Genetic Medicine Reports, 7(3), pp.153-161.

VORONIN,MV&ZAKHAROVA,MV (2018). "Measure of Freedom in the Context of Legal Regulation of Genomic Research: Foreign Experience."Revista Dilemas Contemporáneos: Educación, Política y Valores.

ZAKHAROVA, MV (2020)."The Rosie Effect” or the Dialectics of the Social and the Biological in the Evolution of the Legal Map of the World in the 21st Century."Kutafin University Bulletin (Moscow State Law Academy), pp.50-56.

Cómo citar
VALER’EVICH VORONIN, M., VLADIMIROVNA ZAKHAROVA, M., & VLADIMIROVNA KOZLOVA, N. (2020). Imperative and Dispositive Norms in Legal Regulation of Genetic Research in Russia. / Normas imperativas y dispositivas en la regulación legal de la investigación genética en Rusia. Utopía Y Praxis Latinoamericana, 25(1), 373-381. Recuperado a partir de